"Evidence three, the party has no social security payment records, and the social security center has issued a certification of inability to make supplementary payments." Discover exclusive tales on m,v l'e-NovelHub
"Evidence four, the arbitration document with Hongtong Property Management Company..."
In fact, Gao had already given up in terms of presenting and challenging evidence; when he encountered such evidence in the cases he judged, he basically had the verdict figured out already.
The online community watching Gao question in court felt something truly unique.
"The defendant is talking about historical legacy issues, and it makes me wonder, shouldn't one still be responsible for historical legacy issues? Are they not the ones who did it?"
"I'm also curious, I think Lawyer Tang's demands are fair and reasonable, but the defendant seems to be at a loss for words."
The court investigation finally ended, Old Gao was sweating from his forehead, this situation was torture for him.
Clearly, the other side had complete evidence, and yet he still had to nitpick, which is what he hated most when he himself was judging cases...
If the netizens could hear Old Gao's thoughts, this trial would surely excite them to no end!
The court debate began, and Old Gao continued to argue over the issue of responsibility.
At the same time, the lawyer hired by Li Chang'an began to speak.
"I don't think the Anchang Court should bear all the responsibility; the plaintiff worked in my company for three years, and my company also never paid social security..."
The situation changed after this lawyer began to speak.
The audience and observers were confused, while Old Tang was trying hard to explain that this matter had nothing to do with the outsourcing company because by the time it went to the outsourcing company, paying social security was already pointless.
Yes, it was the original words of Jiang Shubo...
The court was explaining that they had responsibility, but they should not pay money every month; instead, they should work with the company to give the plaintiff a lump sum for the unpaid social security.
The property management company was trying to claim all the fault, saying to bring any issues to them and not to trouble Anchang.
The three parties directly turned the situation into a mess, and it excited the audience, this was real courtroom debate, thrilling!
Human emotions were fully released in this debate.
Finally, after everyone had spoken until they were exhausted, the Judgment Chief reacted and announced, "The court debate is over, now for the final statements."
"I always believe that if you make a mistake, you must admit it and find a way to make amends. Social security was not paid for historical reasons, which I don't deny, but the court, as a judicial body, should have known the consequences of not paying social security."
"Yet they let such a thing happen, so now they must take responsibility, instead of trying to solve it in one go."
"Because social security has its specific nature..."
Of course, at the end of the day, the compensation was too little; they were only willing to pay the previously unpaid social security and didn't want to pay more, which was certainly unacceptable.
"In summary, I hope the court supports our demands."
Old Gao sat down, rubbing his mouth, and said, "Please rule to dismiss the plaintiff's demands."
He already knew that he had lost the case.
The third-party lawyer hesitated for a long time before finally saying, "Please, court... rule that our side bears responsibility."
The netizens could no longer hold back, and various "haha"s started flooding the screen. The rightful source is novel⟡fire.net
The Judgment Chief looked at the lawyer and announced a recess, the audience really wanted to laugh now, the case was too eye-opening.
Finally, upon reconvening, Lanhe County Court believed that Anchang Court and Hongtong Property Management Company both bore certain responsibilities.
After consideration, the court ruled that Anchang Court must pay the plaintiff a retirement insurance amount of 1,500 yuan per month until the plaintiff's death.
The third-party property management company also had responsibility, but they were not the main reason the plaintiff could not enjoy retirement insurance benefits, rendering a discretionary judgment for them to compensate the plaintiff with ten thousand yuan.
After delivering the verdict, Gao began to make phone calls, while elsewhere, inside the office of Anchang District Court, several leaders were in discussion.
"Forget it, let's not appeal, we've already lost enough face; if we appeal, it will only make us lose more. Let's accept it," the director said helplessly.
They could only accept it, knowing all too well about the challenges of a second trial and realizing that the higher court probably had a poor view of them now...
How did things end up ...
The leaders felt helpless, but they noted the name Tang Fangjing.
On the other side, Gao received instructions, and promptly announced without appeal.
Seeing that Anchang Court didn't appeal, the netizens were disappointed, questioning why they didn't fight back and stand their ground!
Everyone really wanted to see a second round, but they backed down...
What's more, the live broadcast was cut shortly after the verdict, adding to the disappointment.
There was a good show going on, why couldn't they fight it out with Old Tang?
After the verdict, Gao came over, looking at Old Tang, who was packing up his things, with a wry smile and said, "Lawyer Tang, you've really made us lose face this time."
Hearing this, Old Tang simply smiled and said, "I can actually understand your situation; after all, the people who were originally managing these issues are gone now, and you are not aware of these matters."
"However, Judge Gao, since the court has made a mistake, it should certainly bear this responsibility, right."
"Alright, I'll be on my way then."
After bidding farewell to Gao, Old Tang picked up his briefcase and walked out. The case had gone through labor arbitration, litigation, and designation of jurisdiction among many other difficulties, but fortunately, there was a result.
The money wasn't much, but it wasn't about the amount; it was about who had the responsibility, and one must bear it, regardless of one's status.