Chapter 655: Chapter 205 Translation, What Is Called Joint Infringement!_3 Chapter 655: Chapter 205 Translation, What Is Called Joint Infringement!_3 “`
The matters online were naturally unknown to the court here, and Ding Deshui was now a bit worried.
Using his junior high school diploma to judge, he thought that bastard with the surname Tang seemed to make sense!
Shit, what’s going on, how could I possibly think he makes sense!
The Judgment Chief’s expression remained unchanged.
After confirming that Old Tang had finished speaking, he allowed the prosecutor to begin.
The prosecutor’s opinion was also very clear: the attacker should not be considered as a whole.
“Firstly, regarding the forced demolition of Huang Licheng’s orchard, our side believes that although the orchard was forcefully demolished, it was not to the urgent extent that violent retaliation was necessary to prevent it.”
“The party involved, Huang Licheng, could have called the police or chosen to protect his legal rights through legal means afterward.
These are ways to resolve the issue, but he prepared a knife in advance and resorted to violence during the demolition, which obviously indicates an intention to provoke trouble!”
“Secondly, the forced demolition of the orchard and the forcible removal of Huang Licheng should be seen as two separate actions…”
Old Tang sat down to drink water but nearly spat it out upon hearing the prosecutor’s opinion.
Shit, you can actually say that, huh?
It’s like Zhu Yuanzhang becoming the emperor and asking those rebellious peasants why they didn’t report their problems to the officials, almost like saying there’s a legal remedy after the fact at that point!
Holding back his anger until the other party finished, and waiting for the Judgment Chief’s permission, Old Tang immediately retorted, “I think there’s a big problem with what the prosecution said.
If we follow their argument, all illegal infringements against property should not be resisted because they can all be remedied afterward.”
“As for calling the police, the evidence shows that Huang Licheng had already called them, only the police hadn’t arrived at that time!”
“For the second point, the prosecution thinks they should be considered as two separate actions, so now, Judgment Chief, I want to ask the prosecution a question.”
The Judgment Chief glanced and then said, “Permission to ask.”
“I want to ask the prosecution whether those three people forcefully removing Huang Licheng was solely to remove him or to facilitate the demolition.”
The prosecutor was momentarily at a loss for words; he couldn’t say it was just to remove him.
Even a child would understand it was to facilitate the demolition.
Then I take it as a default that it was to facilitate the demolition, right?
Since the removal was to facilitate the demolition, where is the reasoning that these are two separate actions?
Just because the people destroying the orchard did not make contact with Huang Licheng?”
“Fine, no talking, no problem.
The removal was to facilitate the demolition, so shouldn’t we have reason to believe that the three people’s actions constitute a joint infringement?”
“And according to the ‘Opinions on the Application of the Self-Defense System Issued by the Supreme People’s Court, Supreme People’s Procuratorate, Ministry of Public Security’ published two years ago, Article 7 clearly stipulates that when multiple people carry out an illegal infringement together, one can defend against those directly executing the illegal act as well as those jointly doing so at the scene.”
“Therefore, the actions of our client can be recognized as justifiable self-defense!” Old Tang said emphatically!
Seeing that the prosecution was still silent, the Judgment Chief looked at Old Tang and said, “Does your side have anything else to add?”
Old Tang leisurely said, “No.”
“Alright, the courtroom debate concludes.”
As soon as the words fell, Ding Deshui was stunned; the only thought in his head was: It seems…
it seems to really make sense, he even thought Huang Licheng swinging that knife was justified.
No, no, how could that be right?
The third brother was covered in blood, how could that be justifiable self-defense?
In fact, Old Tang himself also sighed in relief.
These sorts of things are like setting the agenda, whichever side does it better, wins.
Online netizens were boiling with excitement, and most importantly, Tang Fangjing argued his points very clearly, unlike some lawyers who were full of legalese that sounded lofty but were incomprehensible.
During the adjournment, the live stream was still filled with dense comments.
The netizens were practically fighting with each other.
To put it broadly, legal matters, being in the social sciences, tend to lead to arguments.
In the hard sciences, if you know it, you know it; if you don’t, you don’t.
Academic disputes show a high level of expertise, but in social sciences, anyone can say a few words…
Finally, the collegial panel returned.
“This court believes…
In summary, the verdict is as follows:”
“The verdict of Lincheng City Intermediate People’s Court…
and the accompanying civil judgment are hereby overturned.”
“The original defendant Huang Licheng is acquitted!”
After the verdict was announced, the audience in the courtroom and the online spectators erupted in collective excitement!
“Shit, he’s really acquitted; Tang Fangjing is still awesome!”
“Did you guys hear that?
The key is that the civil judgment was also overturned.
Does that mean all the money paid earlier has to be returned?
Even though this was the second time Old Tang had pulled off such a move, it was still impressively cunning. Nᴇw novel chapters are publɪshed on NovelHub(.)net
Ding Deshui, on the other hand, didn’t react much; he had already anticipated this outcome.
The most important part was that he didn’t understand the meaning of the civil judgment being overturned…
In Tengda, Huang Licheng stared blankly at the computer, then suddenly burst into tears, finally, finally his wrongful conviction had been cleared.
The live broadcast signal was cut off; Wang Jing had already slammed the opposition for not daring to show up and continuously mocked them as old people for typing so slowly.
And Old Tang, he silently packed his things, left the court, and headed straight for the Lincheng City bus station.
He was off to Changlu County, he was going to report a case in Changlu County!
As for evidence, the judgment as well as the evidence previously collected by the Changlu County police authority were the evidence, such as the interrogation record of Huang Licheng by the Changlu County police authorities…